What order should Asimov's Foundation series be read in?
I believe that Asimov himself recommended reading them in chronological order, however I read them in the order that they were published and think that this is the best way to do it.
What is the correct order?
I too read them initially in their order of publication, but now whenever I re-read them I prefer the chronological order, which actually makes more sense.
My favourite full-immersion approach to Asimov is Robots - Empire - Foundation in strict chronological order, and sometimes I also like to add End of Eternity at the beginning.
Since the Foundation series doesn't really have a proper ending, I'd suggest reading *The End OF Eternity* as an epilogue to the series.
I prefer The End of Eternity at the beginning. It makes more sense there. The whole Robots - Empire - Foundation is arguably the result of the actions taken in The End Of Eternity.
For a second reading, it might be nice to frame things... but for a first reading, don't you think that the publication order preserves some of the historical context and mystery better? (Eg. The influence and context of Asimov in WWII... also, I especially enjoyed reading it on an e-reader. It somehow dragged me much more tangibly into the life here on Terminus.)
The author himself, Isaac Asimov, wrote in the Author's Note of the Prelude to Foundation that he is providing a guide for those readers that might appreciate it since the books "were not written in the order in which (perhaps) they should be read." Therein, he offers the following chronological order:
- The Complete Robot (1982) Collection of 31 Short Stories about robots.
- The Caves of Steel (1954) His first Robot novel.
- The Naked Sun (1957) The second Robot novel.
- The Robots of Dawn (1983) The third Robot novel.
- Robots and Empire (1985) The fourth (final) Robot novel.
- The Currents of Space (1952) The first Empire novel.
- The Stars, Like Dust-- (1951) The second Empire novel.
- Pebble in the Sky (1950) The third and final Empire novel.
- Prelude to Foundation (1988) The first Foundation novel.
- Forward the Foundation (1992) The second Foundation novel. (Not in Asimov's list as it had not been written yet.)
- Foundation (1951) The third Foundation novel, comprised of 5 stories originally published between 1942-1949.
- Foundation and Empire (1952) The fourth Foundation novel, comprised of 2 stories originally published in 1945.
- Second Foundation (1953) The fifth Foundation novel, comprised of 2 stories originally published in 1948 and 1949.
- Foundation's Edge (1982) The sixth Foundation novel.
- Foundation and Earth (1983) The seventh Foundation novel.
This list from Prelude to Foundation (1988) is also reproduced online here.
I know that list is the Word Of God, but I have to disagree about Prelude and Forward. They should be *last*. The original trilogy puts Hari Seldon and Psychohistory on a pedestal, like a mysterious and ancient prophet whose wisdom and motives are slowly revealed. Reading the prequels where Hari Seldon is the protagonist developing Psychohistory messes with this. Also the transition from Azimov's 50's writing to his late 80's writing and back is jarring.
I'd nominate Mother Earth and maybe The Psychohistorians short stories for the list since they are in the same setting. Admittedly they don't add much to the plot but are good insight how the author created his universe.
I believe an amended version of this appeared in a later novel (or perhaps a later edition?) - I remember him quoting himself and adding items, including _I, Robot_ (for its linking text, not reproduced in _The Complete Robot_) and the collections _Robot Visions_ and _Robot Dreams_, which contain robot stories not in _The Complete Robot_, as well as _Forward the Foundation_, which as you note post-dated the previous list.
I do quite agree with Schwern, but I'd go further and exclude Forward completely. It is all about old man's bitter feelings and adds nothing to the story save for sad excuse for Second Foundation origins. You just don't do that to an epic sci-fi series.
Can anyone offer clarity on the order of the Empire books? Several sources suggest that The Stars, Like Dust is chronologically before The Currents of Space, which contradicts this list.
Everybody who reads the novels should realize that The Stars like Dust happens unknown thousands of years before The Currents of Space that happens unknown thousands of years before Pebble in the Sky. I always assumed that the list was corrected in later editions of Prelude to Foundation. Asimov simply made a mistake somehow while riting the list - which proves that even creators of stories can get their facts wrong about their own stories.
@Nom1fan for the empire series https://www.goodreads.com/series/43817-galactic-empire
I think neither the published order nor the chronological order do the series justice.
I always have recommended the series in the following order:
- I, Robot (some lists omit this, but this is really the "origin" story of this universe - The Complete Robot can be substituted here, since it contains the same stories as I, Robot)
- The Elijah Baley series (which obliquely tells the story of Earth's first robotic forays into space)
- The Galactic Empire trilogy (since these 3 books are unconnected to each other, besides taking place in the same general universe, this series can really be read in any order)
- The original Foundation Trilogy
- Foundation's Edge
- Foundation and Earth (To me, that is really marks the end of the best of the work, and you can stop there. Or, you can proceed to the later additions to the series, which I find do not hold up as well as the others.)
- Prelude to Foundation
- Forward the Foundation
The reason I like this order is that it preserves the chronology of the reader's discovery of the story. Neither the publication order nor the pure chronological order do this - Prelude and Forward are far weaker entries, and remove some of the mystery the first-time reader would have going into the first Foundation book. Part of the enjoyment of the Foundation novel is that you don't know who Seldon is, in those opening scenes on Trantor, or what role he's going to play in the story. If you read Prelude and Forward first, you'll already have an earful about Trantor and Seldon before you get to Seldon's introduction through Gaal Dornick's eyes in Foundation. I'm also completely ignoring the non-Asimov entries, which in my opinion don't add much to the series.
If you've already read the original Foundation trilogy, I'd recommend going back to the other series before finishing with Foundation's Edge and Foundation and Earth.
For those who have already read the books, I could see some merit in reading them chronologically, but for those who are new to the series, I highly recommend ignoring both the publication order and Asimov's own suggestion on reading order.
- 1954 The Caves of Steel This is the first of the robot novels.
- 1957 The Naked Sun The second robot novel.
- 1983 The Robots of Dawn The third robot novel.
- 1985 Robots and Empire The fourth robot novel.
- 1951 The Stars, Like Dust This is the first of the Empire novels.
- 1952 The Currents of Space The second Empire novel.
- 1950 Pebble in the Sky The third Empire novel, however, it was Asimov's first full novel to be published.
- 1988 Prelude to Foundation This is the first Foundation novel.
- 1997 Foundation's Fear Second Foundation trilogy by Gregory Benford.
- 1993 Forward the Foundation The second Foundation novel (although it was the last written by Asimov himself).
- 1998 Foundation and Chaos Second Foundation trilogy by Greg Bear.
- 1999 Foundation's Triumph Second Foundation trilogy by David Brin.
- 1951 Foundation The third Foundation novel. Actually, it is a collection of four stories, originally published between 1942 and 1944, plus an introductory section written for the book in 1949. Published, slightly abridged, as part of an Ace Double paperback, D-110, with the title "The 1000-Year Plan", in 1955.
- 1952 Foundation and Empire The fourth Foundation novel, made up of two stories, originally published in 1945. This book was originally published with the title 'The Man Who Upset the Universe' as a 35c Ace paperback, D-125, in about 1952.
- 1953 Second Foundation The fifth Foundation novel, made up of two stories, originally published in 1948 and 1949.
- 1982 Foundation's Edge The sixth Foundation novel.
- 1986 Foundation and Earth The seventh Foundation novel.
The first from this list is not from the Foundation series but I suggest you read these books first. I read Asimov in this order.
-1 the Foundation prequels contain major spoilers for the proper Foundation novels; just because they are chronologically earlier doesn't mean they should be read that way.
I am on Book 5 (Foundation and Earth) and so far I have read them in what I think is Chronological order.
That is :
- Foundation and Empire
- Second Foundation
- Foundations Edge
- Foundation and Earth
So far it's been a brilliant read.
I'm reading Foundation and Empire and I'm on chapter 10. Should I stop reading it and go back to "foundation"? I messed the order.
This sounds like publication order, not chronological. "Prelude to Foundation" and "Forward the Foundation" precede Foundation chronologically.
Hey fellow french learners / readers. Here's the list I established before I attacked this series. Titles are in french. I added the English title between parentheses for reference. Format used was
Year - French title (English title).
The Robots series
- 1950 - Les robots (I, Robot)
- 1964 - Un défilé de Robots (The Rest of the Robots)
- 1986 - Le roboot qui rêvait (Robot Dreams)
The Elijah Baley series
- 1953 - Les cavernes d’acier (The Caves of Steel)
- 1956 - Face aux feux du Soleil (The Naked Sun)
- 1983 - Les robots de l’Aube (Robots of Dawn)
- 1985 - Les robots et l’Empire (Robots and Empire)
The Empire series
- 1952 - Les courants de l’Espace (The Currents of Space)
- 1951 - Tyrann (The Stars Like Dust)
- 1950 - Cailloux dans le Ciel (Pebbel in the Sky)
The Foundation Series
- 1951 - Fondation (Foundation)
- 1952 - Foundation et empire (Foundation and Empire)
- 1953 - Seconde Fondation (Second Foundation)
- 1982 - Fondation foudroyée (Foundation’s Edge)
- 1986 - Terre et Fondation (Earth and Foundation)
The Prelude to Foundation
- 1988 - Prélude à Fondation (Prelude to Foundation)
- 1993 - L’aube de Fondation (Forward the Foundation)
I too read the Foundation books in the order that they were published and enjoyed them that way. I did however lend my collection to a friend who decided to start with Prelude to Foundation, and then read the rest in publication order. He insists that it was a great way to read them.
Prelude is a very different book from the original Foundations, so anyone reading that first should be warned about the change. Given that though, it may help make the original Foundation trilogy more exciting to go into it knowing more about Seldon.
I've read them in both publication order and chronological order (inevitable, as I read more than a few of them before the master died, thus before all were published), and they're a good read either way.
Figuring out the chronological order before the definite list was published by Asimov himself was fun, getting it mostly right quite satisfying :)
1.Foundation 2.Foundation and Empire 3.Second Foundation
and ignore the rest. The others don't compare.
I don't think you need to read the series in any particular order relative to each other. For instance, I read
I, Robotand other Susan Calvin books before jumping straight into the
The Robots of Dawnsomewhere in between. So it was a bit of a shock when:
I found out that Earth had been abandoned thanks to the machinations of that sweet little mind-reading robot and his humanoid robot friend when I finally read
Robots and Empire. And that everything in the Foundation books had been a massive Xanatos Gambit engineered by said humanoid robot friend when I got to
Foundation and Earth.
But I think each individual series ought to be read in sequence: you're going to get major spoilers if you read
Second Foundationbefore you read
Foundation and Empire, for instance.
To be honest, I was never *entirely* sure that the Foundation series referred to humans at all. They were 'human like' but I don't think it was underlined that they were of human origin specifically. I figured lacking robots it was either 'not humans' or a different canon (there is no law saying an author must stick to only one series with its own type of universe). When the books came that tied together the two universes, it was a surprise to me!