When is a cooking oil not appropriate to substitute for another?

  • Frequently recipes call for a particular kind of oil for making use of certain characteristics (taste, heat tolerance, health, etc.). It's well known you can substitute cooking oils in most cases (vegetable oil for canola oil).

    Are there circumstances in which it is not appropriate to substitute cooking oils?

    You mean other than when things like taste, heat tolerance, health, etc are factors? Or is that what you are asking?

    No, I mean any reason. That's why "etc." is on the list. I was just giving examples as to why one chooses an oil over another.

  • Aaronut

    Aaronut Correct answer

    10 years ago

    Actually, there are really only a few oils you can substitute for each other, at least without any significant side effects.

    The oils which generally are used interchangeably are peanut oil, canola/rapeseed oil, and sunflower oil. These oils have similar smoke points, don't impart any really noticeable flavour, and tend to be used primarily for high-heat cooking (pan-frying, deep-frying), so if you're paranoid about saturated fat for instance, you can substitute sunflower oil for peanut oil. Corn oil is in the same group, but I rarely see that used anymore. You can also use the "light" olive oil, but that will change the flavour of the dish. I believe walnut oil has similar properties, but it's considerably harder to find.

    But keep in mind that oils are used for far more than frying. Many have highly-specialized uses:

    • Extra virgin olive oil is most commonly used in sauces and salad dressings ("oil and vinegar" almost always means olive oil, there really is no substitute);

    • Chili oil is really more of a condiment than a cooking oil. Even if you could cook with it, the result would be inedible due to the heat.

    • Toasted sesame oil is used as a flavourings in Asian dishes. It's useless as a cooking oil (and cooking with it would be a terrible waste). Regular sesame oil, on the other hand, is often bought in a refined form and is generally used as a cooking oil.

    • There are a lot of other more esoteric types of oil such as palm oil and coconut oil, which you really don't want to use unless you know what you're doing (you can ruin the flavour).

    I could go on, but for now I'll refer you to the Types of oils and their characteristics as a starting point. Cooking oils really aren't freely interchangeable in all situations; even if you've accounted for smoke point and flavour, sometimes a significantly different fat content (i.e. grapeseed oil which is mostly polyunsaturated vs. canola oil which is mostly monounsaturated) can seriously mess up a delicate recipe.

    It's better to be asking which oils you can substitute in a specific situation than to assume everything goes and list the "exceptional" circumstances.

    A great all-around answer about oils in cooking. I was hoping for a little more info on frying oils, perhaps a little less on condiment/flavor oils, but still you provide a good resource.

License under CC-BY-SA with attribution


Content dated before 6/26/2020 9:53 AM