Is there a problem with defrosting meat on the counter?

  • I generally defrost meat on the kitchen counter. A friend of mine suggested that this was dangerous and suggested that I defrost meat in the refrigerator. I am no biologist but it seems to me that as long as the meat doesn't get warm defrosting it on the counter should be safe.

    Generally, I remove the frozen items from the freezer and place them on a plate on the counter in the packaging they were frozen in. When they are mostly / completely thawed I place the meat in the refrigerator.

    Am I wrong and should I be defrosting in the refrigerator?

  • yossarian

    yossarian Correct answer

    10 years ago

    A lot of bacteria grows in the range of 40-100°F (4-38°C) (i.e. room temperature). It's definitely not recommended to defrost meat at room temperature. In fact, you are not supposed to leave meat at room temperature for more than an hour.

    However, defrosting in the refrigerator can take a long time and require you to plan at least one day ahead of time. I'm not so good at this, which leads to a safe and fast solution: Defrost meat in a waterproof ziploc bag in cold water. Change the water every 30 minutes until defrosted. The water is a better conductor of heat than air, so the defrosting is quite fast and the water is cold so there's minimal safety risk.

    From the USDA:

    Uh, oh! You're home and forgot to defrost something for dinner. You grab a package of meat or chicken and use hot water to thaw it fast. But is this safe? What if you remembered to take food out of the freezer, but forgot and left the package on the counter all day while you were at work?

    Neither of these situations are safe, and these methods of thawing lead to foodborne illness. Food must be kept at a safe temperature during "the big thaw." Foods are safe indefinitely while frozen. However, as soon as food begins to defrost and become warmer than 40 °F (4 °C), any bacteria that may have been present before freezing can begin to multiply.

    Foods should never be thawed or even stored on the counter, or defrosted in hot water. Food left above 40 °F (unrefrigerated) is not at a safe temperature.

    Even though the center of the package may still be frozen as it thaws on the counter, the outer layer of the food is in the "Danger Zone," between 40 and 140 °F (4 °C and 60 °C) – at temperatures where bacteria multiply rapidly.

    When defrosting frozen foods, it's best to plan ahead and thaw food in the refrigerator where food will remain at a safe, constant temperature – 40 °F (4 °C) or below.

    There are three safe ways to defrost food: in the refrigerator, in cold water, and in the microwave.

    Refrigerator Thawing Planning ahead is the key to this method because of the lengthy time involved. A large frozen item like a turkey requires at least a day (24 hours) for every 5 pounds of weight. Even small amounts of frozen food -- such as a pound of ground meat or boneless chicken breasts -- require a full day to thaw. When thawing foods in the refrigerator, there are several variables to take into account. Some areas of an appliance may keep the food colder than other areas. Food placed in the coldest part will require longer defrosting time. Food takes longer to thaw in a refrigerator set at 35 °F (2 °C) than one set at 40 °F (4 °C).

    After thawing in the refrigerator, ground meat and poultry should remain useable for an additional day or two before cooking; red meat, 3 to 5 days. Foods defrosted in the refrigerator can be refrozen without cooking, although there may be some loss of quality.

    Cold Water Thawing

    This method is faster than refrigerator thawing but requires more attention. The food must be in a leak-proof package or plastic bag. If the bag leaks, bacteria from the air or surrounding environment could be introduced into the food. Also, meat tissue can also absorb water like a sponge, resulting in a watery product.

    The bag should be submerged in cold tap water, changing the water every 30 minutes so it continues to thaw. Small packages of meat or poultry – about a pound – may defrost in an hour or less. A 3- to 4-pound package may take 2 to 3 hours. For whole turkeys, estimate about 30 minutes per pound. If thawed completely, the food must be cooked immediately.

    Foods thawed by the cold water method should be cooked before refreezing.

    Actually water is a relatively poor conductor of heat. It's just better than air and has a high thermal capacity.

    Ok, maybe "excellent" is too strong a word, but it is far more efficient than air, and you're unlikely to put your food into something that'll work better.

    Fair enough. :)

    @hobodave, although looking up thermal conductivity on wikipedia did yield some interesting ideas. Lead is pretty good, but diamonds would really work wonders! ;o) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_conductivity#Experimental_values

    ooh.. how's that for a kintchen unitasker, diamond constructed defrost bags. "garrenteed to defrost better and fast than Ziploc"

    What I don't understand, and the above article doesn't seem to address it, is if I cook the food all the way through, why does it matter how much bacteria was allowed to multiply while it was at room temperature? As far as I know the amount of bacteria is irrelevant to the rate the bacteria die at.

    @Carcigenicate Because it's not the bacteria you need to worry about but the heat-stable toxins they produce

License under CC-BY-SA with attribution


Content dated before 6/26/2020 9:53 AM