Order of combining wet and dry ingredients when baking

  • I've always learnt that you add the wet ingredients to the dry ones.

    Looking at some recipes:

    "Combine the dry ingredients, the flour ... Add the other wet ingredients, melted butter ..."

    "Pour wet ingredients into dry and mix until just combined"

    "Mix dry ingredients together, Mix wet ingredients together, and Combine wet and dry together and bake!"

    "Make a well in the dry ingredients and then pour the wet ingredients into the well and mix"

    Is there a reason to always add wet to dry and not the other way around?

    Are there any types of recipes that , in fact, reverse the order?

    With a mixer, if you add the dry to the wet, it's more likely to make a spray of poweder all over the place ... but I admit, I was wonder the same thing the other day, if there were other reasons for one vs. the other.

    @Joe Good point. I sometimes watch cookery shows on TV, and if it's about baking, usually there's a mantra of _start with the dry ingredients, and end with the dry ingredients_. But nobody ever actually explained why to do that ... maybe you did ;-)

  • The dry ingredients are lighter, less dense, and less viscous than the wet, which means they'll have a tendency to float on top of the wet. The dry ingredients that come in contact with the wet will form a sort-of skin, preventing the wet from distributing throughout the dry. You end up with clumps of dry, unmixed, and (ultimately) uncooked dry ingredients.

    Pouring wet into dry forces agitation and more uniform distribution.

    I've found that frequently in mixers if dry ingredients are on the bottom, they'll never totally mix in, living a layer of unmixed flour at the bottom. Wet ingredients on the bottom will get pulled up by the dry ingredients though. Perhaps this could be a difference of using a mixer vs doing it by hand?

    I think that's why you normally see batched inclusion of dry into wet when using a stand mixer. It'll produce a different consistency, but that doesn't make it bad.

License under CC-BY-SA with attribution


Content dated before 6/26/2020 9:53 AM