What are the differences between men's and women's bike frames?

  • Why do women's bikes have a diagonal bar in the frame instead of a horizontal frame? Is this the only difference?

    Sorry if this has been asked (but I cannot find it by searching) and I also just cannot think of a reason why.

    I always compare it to the difference between fiddles and violins.

    @WTHarper just casually asking someone, they mentioned it might be dress related...skirts or dresses might be more accommodated with the diagonal bar...but that was a guess...

    @davidsleeps - Way, way, way back in the mists of history women rode horses side-saddle and rode "women's bikes" in dresses. Hence the slanted top tube. (However, I happen to know a 50-something woman who frequently rides in a skirt, but rides a "men's" bike.)

  • mikes

    mikes Correct answer

    8 years ago

    Way back when safety bikes were becoming popular, women wore skirts. Skirt lengths were to the ankle. The dropped top bar made getting on possible while maintaining respectability. Women were considered too fragile to risk hitting the top tube, hence the slanted bar. The trend continued even long after women stopped riding in long skirts.

    Modern WSD (women specific design) geometry differs from conventional bike geometry. The difference goes beyond just size. Whether it is needed depends on who you ask. While some women may be smaller than the average male, many are as tall; height is not the only issue. Many women have a different leg to torso ratio than the male average and the frames are built to fit that difference. This is not to say that a women needs a female specific frame or that a male wouldn't fit on a WSD frame. It all depends on the individual physical traits of the rider.

    Some of us still bike in long skirts. Just sayin'. :)

    The difference between then and now is now you do it by choice

    Differing leg/torso ratios are handled by top-tube sizing for any given seat-tube length. I think the OP is asking about step-through frames-- not just sloping top-tubes like on compact geometry frames for road bikes.

    mikes: Agreed. I just thought "long after women stopped riding in long skirts" was a tad bit overstated.

    I have seen no evidence that leg to torso ratios actually differ by gender. It is my understanding that this is a myth and that there is more variation within gender than between gender (i.e., not statistically different)

    @Rider_X do you have a source for this? Very interesting.

License under CC-BY-SA with attribution

Content dated before 6/26/2020 9:53 AM